Mass migration drives Americans out of the workforce, Stephen Miller explains

The Changing Workforce and Its Impact on American Jobs

The American workforce has undergone significant changes over the years, raising concerns about job availability, wages, and employment opportunities. A major factor influencing this shift is mass migration, which has altered the dynamics of many industries.

In the past, jobs such as cab driving, construction work, and entry-level service positions were primarily held by American-born workers. For example, in the 1980s, most taxi drivers in New York City were native New Yorkers. They would often engage with passengers, sharing insights about the city’s attractions and culture. However, today, a significant percentage of cab drivers are foreign-born. While this is not a criticism of immigrant workers, it highlights how certain job sectors have evolved due to immigration patterns.

This shift extends beyond the transportation industry. Many fast-food restaurants and other entry-level positions are now filled by foreign-born workers, particularly in areas with high immigration rates. Conversely, in regions with lower immigration levels, it is still common to see American high school students working in such roles to earn extra income. This change has raised concerns about the long-term impact on American workers, particularly young people who historically relied on these jobs as stepping stones into the workforce.

A key argument often presented in support of increased immigration is that immigrants take jobs that Americans do not want. However, historical evidence contradicts this claim. Industries that built America—such as construction, plumbing, and electrical work—were once dominated by American workers. The labor force that constructed the Empire State Building, the Panama Canal, and the interstate highway system was overwhelmingly American. These jobs provided a pathway to the middle class and were considered respectable and well-paying careers.

Over time, public perception of skilled trades has been negatively affected. Pop culture has contributed to the downgrading of professions like plumbing and welding, making them seem undesirable. As a result, fewer young Americans are pursuing careers in these fields, while foreign workers fill the gaps. The influx of cheap labor has led to lower wages and reduced job attractiveness, discouraging many Americans from entering these industries.

To address this issue, several measures have been proposed. Reforming welfare policies and adjusting incentive structures could encourage more American workers to enter the labor market. Additionally, limiting mass migration could help stabilize wages and make certain jobs more financially viable for American families. By promoting the dignity and economic viability of skilled trades, the country could restore these professions as respectable career options.

Another significant policy proposal is establishing English as the official language of the United States. Proponents argue that a unifying national language would foster assimilation, integration, and a stronger national identity. This move would not only streamline communication but also reinforce shared cultural values.

In summary, the evolving workforce landscape has profound implications for American jobs and wages. Addressing these challenges requires a combination of policy reforms, cultural shifts, and renewed respect for skilled trades. By taking these steps, the U.S. can create an economy that prioritizes American workers while maintaining a balanced and sustainable labor market.