Sara Bareilles is a talented singer and songwriter known for her strong and emotional music. One of her most famous songs is “She Used to Be Mine,” which she wrote for her Broadway musical Waitress. Recently, Sydnie Christmas put her own spin on this Broadway favorite, adding new life and excitement to the beloved song. Her special version of the song caught everyones’ attention, showing that this song can still be seen in new and creative ways.

She Used To Be Mine

When Bareilles released the song as part of her album “What’s Inside: Songs from Waitress” back in 2015, it quickly became a favorite. “She Used to Be Mine” tells the story of Jenna, a waitress who feels lost and reflects on her life. The lyrics are emotional and relatable, capturing how people often feel when they look back on their dreams and compare them to their current reality. The line “she is all of this mixed up and baked in a beautiful pie” perfectly sums up the mix of emotions Jenna experiences.

 

The song has a beautiful tune with piano, guitar, and drums, making it touching and easy to remember. Critics have called it “gentle, emotional, and full of drama.” Many people think it’s one of the best parts of the musical, showing off Bareilles’ amazing singing and deep emotions. If you haven’t heard the original yet, listen to it below:

Sara Bareilles – She Used To Be Mine (Official Video)

In the musical, this song appears in Act 2 when Jenna is deep in thought about her life choices. Bareilles explained that she wrote it for a scene where Jenna feels hopeless about her situation and reflects on who she thought she would become . This theme resonates with many people, showing that everyone struggles with their identity at some point.

Interestingly, the song has reached beyond Broadway. Bareilles mentioned that its message speaks to a wide audience, not just women. She noted that “the chasm between who we are and who we thought we would be is always something we’re negotiating.” This means that everyone can relate to feeling different from their younger selves.

“She Used to Be Mine” remains an important piece of music that touches hearts everywhere. Whether performed live or listened to at home, it’s a song that encourages reflection and connection among all its listeners.