Dylan Dreyer, Hoda Kotb

Dylan Dreyer is one of the many who are looking forward to learning who will replace Hoda Kotb on Today.

On Sept. 26, Kotb announced she would be leaving her duties as co-anchor on the long-running morning show. The news of her departure shocked devoted fans and begged the question, who will step forward to fill the broadcaster’s big shoes?

While she considers Kotb, 60, the “heart and soul of The Today Show,” Dreyer opened up about who she thinks could be her replacement once she steps back from her role. The Third Hour of Today cohost, 43, told E! News that anyone in her “family” of colleagues — including Craig Melvin, Sheinelle Jones, Carson Daly and Weekend Today anchors Peter Alexander and Laura Jarrett — would be perfect for the job.

TODAY, Al Roker, Craig Melvin, Savannah Guthrie, Hoda Kotb and Carson Daly on Thursday, February 9, 2023

“I don’t think if they named anyone in our core group of people it would be surprising,” she confessed. “We’ve all filled in along the way when somebody’s out. I don’t know if anybody’s made any decisions yet, but if it’s one of the core group, I really don’t think it’s that surprising.”

When asked if she’d consider herself for the role, Dreyer joked, “Everybody knows I’m trying to get Al Roker to retire, let’s be honest.”

The weather forecaster also admitted that the news of Kotb’s exit came as a complete surprise.

“I knew about 10 minutes before the show started,” she shared. “Which, I think, is when everybody kind of found out.”

Moments before publicly announcing her departure on the NBC morning show, Kotb wrote a letter to her staff detailing her reasons behind the decision.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“As I write this, my heart is all over the map,” she wrote. “I know I’m making the right decision, but it’s a painful one. And you all are the reason why. They say two things can be right at the same time, and I’m feeling that so deeply right now. I love you and it’s time for me to leave the show.”

“My broadcast career has been beyond meaningful, a new decade of my life lies ahead, and now my daughters and my mom need and deserve a bigger slice of my time pie,” she continued. “I will miss you all desperately, but I’m ready and excited.”

Kotb is slated to conclude her duties in early 2025 but she is still “gonna stay in the NBC family.”